Catching Fire Fan Cast: Who Should Play Plutarch Heavensbee?
Let’s keep fan casting ‘Catching Fire‘!
Next up is Plutarch Heavensbee, the Head Gamemaker of the 75th Annual Hunger Games. If you need more of a refresher on Suzanne’s description of Plutarch, take a look at our Character Profile.
Plutarch is really only described as being a ‘large man‘, leaving casting decisions wide open. We’ve compiled some fan favorites to play the Head Gamemaker, take a look at the list below and cast your vote in our poll!
And don’t forget to voice your opinion in the rest of our Casting Polls!
- Jared Harris
- John Goodman
- Philip Seymour Hoffman
- Kenneth Branagh
- Robert Downey Jr
- Tim Taylor
- Stephen Fry
- Paul Giamatti
- Brian Cox
- Dan Aykroyd
- Jeff Bridges
- Mark Addy
- Oliver Platt
- Jeremy Renner
- Gerard Butler
- Neil Patrick Harris
- Cillian Murphy
- Stephen Tobolowsky
Category: Casting Polls, Catching Fire, News, The Books



























Jared Harris, Stephen Fry or Dan Aykroyd.. IMO Plutarch Heavensbee is at least in his fifties, so Cillian Murphy, Neil Harris and Jeremy Renner doesn’t quite seem to fit in.. They aren’t particularly large either..
Jhon Goodman. it’s just like i pictured Plutach while reading Mockingjay.
EXACTLY!!!!
John Goodman or Jeff Bridges in my opionion. They dont look to old not the skinny not to big and dont look in their 20′s or 30′s perfect in my opionion
I pictured someone like Stephen Fry to play Plutarch Heavensbee
If Jeff Bridges got the role Jennifer would go nuts shes a huge fan so i kinda hope he becomes plutarch
Hahahah, that would be really cool!
Who doesnt love him?
i think if you aged robert downey jr. a bit he could play plutarch. he’s who i pictured during the books.
Tim Taylor (Plutarch is also described as being a gamemaker before becoming the head and he played a gamemaker role clearly in The Hunger Games and he looks close to how I pictured Plutarch. LoL this is like the third time I’ve said this, but I think it would be cool! Though it isn’t something that HAS to happen for me to be happy.)
Or
John Goodman
Also, did anyone ever think Jim Broadbent (Professor Slughorn, Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince) would make a good Plutarch? Maybe. It just came to me.
he could!! he’d be really good!
I always had Jim Broadbent down for Heavensbee, I think he’d be perfect for the role, haha.
Yeah, if he looked anything like his role as Harold in Moulin Rouge! It’s a very Capitol like look.
The guy who played Gaius Baltar, James Callis, in Battle Star Galactica. He was fantastic, serious acting chops and he looks the right age.
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0130536/
I don’t think Robert Downey Jr. I love him and he’s an amazing actor! But i never imagined him as Plutarch, well that’s what i think!
for some reason I pictured Plutarch as looking somthing like the guy that played Seneca Crane in the first movie so i choose Robert Downy jr.
mmmmm gerard butler sexy…….. but this fits John Goodman that’s my vote! but if we have to have gerard than I’ll enjoy the eye candy
I pictured Brendan Gleeson. The guy who played Menalaus in Troy. He also played a role in the Raven
Are these people high? Were they drug tested before taking this poll?
-Bewiched
If Gerard Butler or Neil Patrick-Harris was in Catching fire or Mockingjay… I may just die of happiness. I mean, they are nowhere near what I pictured Plutarch looking like but they are two of my favourite male actors and I would just die of happiness.
I am not sure who I like, but I pictured him being a little more fit than some of the options, especially given the comments on how in the Capitol people get alterations to be fit and thin and young looking and that is a status symbol, opposed to the Districts where some one who reaches old age or is overweight it means they have achieved some success because they are not starving. For that reason, I think I like Neil Patrick Harris.
Jeff Bridges, Paul Giamati, RDJ and Jared Harris all get my vote! Also, Andy Serki. He could NAIL Plutarch!!!
He’s not listed here but I also thought James Gandolfini would be good…
Someone should make jeff bridges unrecognizable and use him for plutarch, just cause it would be comical
okay If in the movie they show the guy who falls in the punch bowl (in first one) thats who should play him because i think the second book says when katniss is dancing with him she says “oh, your the guy who,” and before that she remembers that was him…
I sorta agree with you however I didn’t see them show the guy falling in the punch bowl. I know this because my mother and I discussed the fact that that was something they cut out.
DEFF ROBERT DOWMEY JR!!!!!!!!!!!
without a doubt Cillian Murphy! He’s exactly how i imagined Plutarch! He’s perfect and a amazing,talanted actor
Kenneth Branagh is EXACTLY how I pictured Plutarch while reading the books.
All wrong…besides maybe Jeff Bridges. My vote is for Lawrence Fishburne
olivier platt would be great for this part. He has that ‘sparkle’, like plutchard
Samuel L. Jackson
HAHAHAHAHA YES!!!
I think Alec Baldwin should play Plutach. But I think John Goodman would play a good Plutach also.
I picture Philip Seymour Hoffman or Dan Aykroyd playing him, but Paul Giamatti or John Goodman would be awesome too.
I think either John Goodman or Stephen Fry.
Definantly John Goodman! It’s how I pictured Heavensbee while reading. PERFECT FIT!!!!!!!!!
There are some imdb cast lists with a bunch of great suggestions. Here are just a few of the ones I’ve found.
http://www.imdb.com/list/FpJDA9Bs4xQ/
http://www.imdb.com/list/DXhoaV0OUSo/
http://www.imdb.com/list/8MbR5chejHY/
http://www.imdb.com/list/jX0NKJgzzLI/
http://www.imdb.com/list/nmBcS4R6Ss4/
I agree with Angelina and Alexis!Jeff Bridges or John Goodman would be great but I really like Jeff Bridges!But I totally agree with Alexis if Robert Downey Jr aged a little he would be absolutley PERFECT!!!!! BUT I think Robert Downey Jr now is good too!Him or Jeff Bridges!!!!!
I know it’s already been done but I can still see Tim Taylor as Plutarch.
i think john goodman will be amazing for the role he is just how i pictured plutarch to be, but philip seymour hoffman will be qreat too