twilight vs. harry potter

[Mia106]

I liked the plot, but not how it was written

[missingllama]

i think it was meant to have a casual writing style, not fantastic, yknow? Bree's a very downtrodden character, so it makes sense.

So I just read it, and to be honest, I think that a girl in my english class can poop out a better story...

LOL!!!!!!

[Mia106]

I'm not joking, I need to go read the Hunger Games now to prove to myself not all books are that bad

[kiralouise]

If we're going to get on that, I think the first Hunger Games book was written just as well as Bree Tanner...

[missingllama]

[Mia106]

If we're going to get on that, I think the first Hunger Games book was written just as well as Bree Tanner...

I have to disagree, the character's appealed to you more in the Hunger Games (even the minor characters, Cato, Clove, Rue, Thresh, Foxface), plus, the plot was better in the Hunger Games.

[kiralouise]

I know, I know, I'm bad.

But I'm not talking about plot (even though Bree's plot is very, very well developed, seeing as it fills in the gaps that the other books missed), I'm not talking about characterisation. I'm talking about the eloquency and quality of the writing.

[Mia106]

I hated Bree, I hated everyone about that book (and Twillight in genneral), I liked vampires (not ones that sparkle) and werewolves (not ones that date mortal women) so that was the only thing good about hte books, though I hated the vampires in the books

[kiralouise]

...

If you hated the first book why did you read the whole series?

[Mia106]

I find it hard to put down a series, even if I don't like them (besides for Gone, but that was because I was young when I read it, so I didn;t understand it)
And all my friends where like "OMG TEAM EDWARD!"